"Mom, when can I buy a school lunch?" are the first words out of Kid #1 each day. He just started first grade and this is the first time that school lunch has been available.
What I would like to say in response is "NEVER! No self respecting, food conscience mom would let their children eat green/grey meat, or fruit snacks that (no joke) say CONTAINS PORK PRODUCTS."
But I don't, because I painfully see that it's important to him to eat what he deems looks delicious. And more importantly, what his friends are eating.
His whole six years of life I have been able to avoid most fast food (we do venture to In and Out every few months, and he's been to Mc'D's once with Hubby and once with my parents. That's it for the fast food. That's not to say we don't go out for ice cream--we do that often. I find it much easier for kids to understand that dessert food is a treat, as opposed the a fast food burger; which a burger itself isn't the problem it's the quality of ingredients that make it healthy/unhealthy.
Although we talk about food quality constantly, I am fighting a system that says "school lunch is healthy and balanced." Which makes my head spin. Clearly meat does not normally come in those shades or texture.
What is a food conscience parent supposed to do?
To answer this, I called out the big guns: my friend is a well regarded local head shrinker ( I say that lovingly, of course). She is a great resource, as well as friend. I think every mom should have a Head Shrinker friend to bounce ideas/thoughts off of. She is so smart and calm not to mention super healthy, both in mind and body. She specializes in children/teenagers including those with eating disorders. Her diagnosis/prognosis on my school lunch issue: let him have school lunch once a week.
ONCE A WEEK? I think I almost passed out. She asked, in her very professional voice, "is that going to be difficult for you?"
Frankly YES, was my response. That is going to be extremely difficult.
I know I might sound like an obsessed freak, but why me? Why, after years of teaching (some say brainwashing...I stick to teaching) does my kid want to eat school food? It's so gross! Why can't he see that?
So this is the bottom line, from the Doc: do not qualify food. Give them a good foundation at home, teach them about nutrition and healthy choices, but do not give them a sense of deprivation. A feeling of deprivation leads to food issues down the road.
The last thing I want is my kid to have food issues as an adult. You know, those kids who go off to college and do nothing but binge.
I did not binge in college, nor have I eaten poorly (for extended periods) at any point in my life. What did my parents do? Probably nothing intentionally, but they never qualified food. Food was never an issue.
At home we ate real, home cooked food. Mom packed my lunch almost all of the time, but I clearly remember eating school lunch (and I am sure it was just as gross back then--same school district as my kids are in now). I remember eating fast food occasionally, although not past high school. That's right, I have not stepped into a Mc'Ds since high school. I'm 33.
So this is it, this is where I am. I had to write it down. I feed my kids 35 meals a week, approximately. That's 3 square meals and two snacks (I probably do it more often because little kid #2 still grazes). 35 meals a week and I am most concerned with the five he eats at school. 35 meals a week, and I am stressed out about letting him eat school lunch once a week. 35 meals a week.
And so last night, in a moment of internal angst, I calmly told Kid #1 that he could buy a school lunch once a week. I didn't make it a big deal. His response was, "Cool mom, thanks. I would like to buy the day that there are Cheetos." (sad moment for me)
Here is my response to any criticisms: While I understand nutrition, I also understand human behavior. I understand that a sense of deprivation in regards to food, likely leads to future eating problems.
Hello Kitty Birthday Cake
22 hours ago





10 comments:
Very interesting post. While I don't have kids I get anxious just thinking about things like school lunches. When I was a kid that was ALL I WANTED but my mom always refused. We never had junk food at home, or sugar cereals. And when I'd go to friends' houses I'd eat up all the junk food in their house like a pig! I think you made a good choice.
I am having similar issues with my daughter's "school" lunches. She is 18 months old, and has recently started boycotting dinner. And breakfast at home. Why, you ask? Because I don't cook with msg, HFCS, or excess amounts of salt.
We are looking at some new daycare options that serve organic "home cooked" meals. I love the people that work at her current childcare, but when I show up and all 6 1-2 year olds are eating Nilla wafers at 5 pm.....mommas gotta force a change.
Good for you for allowing a weekly school lunch. I have to admit, I'd pick Cheetos day too!
I have to agree with the shrink on this one.
In 1st grade I let my oldest son get school lunch as many times as he wanted. I think he tried everything and in the end decided it wasn't his favorite. In second grade he did not want school lunch even one time.
I always let my kids try everything good or what's considered junk. I think the more issues we have about food whether it's eating junk or even healthy obsessed gives them issues. I believe they will always come back to the good food. My kids always do...becuase the truth is what makes the kids really uncomfortable and feeling like freaks in front of their peers are the ones who haven't tried Oreo's or donuts or whatever. After weeks of crap lunches and having to wait in line, he probably won't want it anyway.
My son said who is starting second grade recently said to me: "you make the best school lunch." I was shocked.
I've worked since he's been in school. There were many days as a single mom that I was tired and out of ideas. He went to a hippie school that had quality school lunches. But he still preferred to pack a lunch.
Monday he starts in a new public school. After reading Fast Food Nation I don't want him to touch the meat!
But balance is a good idea - too much on one side and we alienate ourselves from society (in my opinion). They may be healthy but pay for it by being disconnected from classmates or colleagues. Also, make it special by restricting it too much and they'll seek that food out as a treat their whole lives.
Here's our favorite school lunch additions:
- pre-popped bag of popcorn
- tupperware with cut up veggies and dip
- pieces of ham
- slices of bread
- water bottle with flavoring packet
Your post made me smile. If my some of my aunts had a say, my son would eat cooked barley and grain mix pancakes every day for lunch.
Janet
Thanks for the comments, please keep them coming. Many people benefit from them.
Train a child up in the way he should go and he will not depart from it. That has always stuck in mind mind when i raised my kids. And it applies to all aspects of a child's life. Now your son may be curious about school lunches and want to try it, but i believe you've given him a good foundation as far as food goes and he won't depart from it. I think you should listen to your friend the shrink.
Nice post. I agree that you should let him do it at least once a week. Especially since 95% of the rest of the day you are doing such an awesome job. Perhaps even an extra snack to accompany the lunch would add a nice boost (like ants on a log or sheets of nori).
The other thing I was going to suggest is making your version of the school lunch that weekend. See if your son will make it with you and talk/interact at that level to explain how your ingredients are different from schools - I know you have probably had those convos, but I think with it being fresh in his mind about what it tasted like that week, and showing him that you can always do it better at home, he will be able to put it together better.
One more idea is to do mini research projects on the various foods - like cheetos. And perhaps balance it out with something that will have more positive results like broccoli or nutritional yeast :) - that way he doesn't walk away feeling blah about food, but gets it clearly that some are bad and exactly why.
Keep up the good work. They will be fine :)
I have the same issues with my first grader. He has also asked me every day to "please, please, please" let him buy school lunch. So, after talking with you, Amanda, and my very knowledgeable and health conscience mother-in-law, I also decided to try the once-a-week approach. However, my son is not aware yet of the lunch menu. I did not sit down with him and read through his options. That way I can look through the lunch menu and I can pick the days he gets to have school lunch! It will be a big surprise for him that morning. Something like this.. "Do you want to buy lunch today, sweetheart?". "Yes, please, mommy!". "ok, son.. go ahead!". "Thanks, mommy, you're the best!". (OK, maybe I'm exaggerating with the superb manners, but this is how things sound in my fantasy world!). Either way, he thinks he is deciding, but it is really my choice. I think it is a win-win situation! Eventually he will figure out that we have a menu to pick from, but for now he need not know!
So, he had his first school lunch today. I asked him all about it and he told me he picked chicken nuggets over the cheeseburger, which are probably still horrible but I thought maybe the lesser of the two evils. He picked grapes as a side and I was SHOCKED to see that his Cheetos were unopened in his backpack! Yay! He did ask for them after we got home for his afternoon snack and I allowed him to eat them, but I was surprised to see that it was not the first thing he ate for lunch! Hopefully he too will learn that school lunches are not "all that..and a bag of chips"!
This is a really interesting issue. Not having children myself, I don't bump up against the issue of school lunches. But, I'm intellectually interested.
I grew up in a healthy household myself (with few food choices beyond what mom packed in my lunch) -- and I have to admit that I spent lots of time trading away wholesome food to other kids for junk! In retrospect, not such a great idea. But, I think giving kids some choices can be a good thing. And it might set the stage for better food choices in the long run.
Wow this is a great resource.. I’m enjoying it.. good article
Post a Comment